← all sources

Landau, Lifshitz — *Mechanics* (Fast Track 1.02) — Audit + Gap Plan

Book: L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics (Volume 1 of the Course of Theoretical Physics).

  • Russian original: Mekhanika, Nauka, Moscow, 1958.
  • 3rd English edition: translated by J. B. Sykes and J. S. Bell, Butterworth-Heinemann, 1976; reprinted continuously through 2000. Pagination and section references in this plan are to the 3rd English edition (vii + 169 pp.).

Fast Track entry: 1.02 — the classical-mechanics anchor of Section 1 of the booklist (after 1.01 Shilov Linear Algebra, before 1.03 Classical Theory of Fields). Catalog status: BUY (under active copyright; Pergamon / Butterworth-Heinemann commercial title).

Audit completeness: full. Local PDF resolved at reference/textbooks-extra/Vol 1 - Landau, Lifshitz - Mechanics (3rd ed, 1976).pdf (7.3 MB, the canonical Sykes-Bell translation). The catalog flags 1.02 as BUY-only, but a copy was already in reference/textbooks-extra/; full TOC and key sections (Ch. I-VII) inventoried directly. WebFetch fallback was not needed.

Purpose: lightweight audit-and-gap pass (P1-lite + P2 + P3-lite). Output is a punch-list of new units and existing-unit deepenings so that Mechanics is covered to the FT-equivalence threshold (≥95% effective coverage; see docs/plans/FASTTRACK_EQUIVALENCE_PLAN.md §3.4). Not a full P1 audit — Landau's 251 Problems are inventoried at chapter level only.

Substantial overlap with the Arnold plan (plans/fasttrack/arnold-mathematical-methods.md). Landau Vol 1 and Arnold cover the same canonical material — least action, Lagrangian, Hamiltonian, canonical transformations, Hamilton-Jacobi, action-angle, adiabatic invariants — with opposite editorial choices (Landau: physicist-coordinates-first, examples-driven, 169 pp; Arnold: geometer-manifolds-first, theorem-driven, 500+ pp). The Arnold batch (items 1-7, 11-13) has already shipped the Codex equivalents of Landau Chapters I-II and VII. This Landau plan does not double-count those units; it itemises Landau-distinctive deepenings and the worked-example layer Landau is canonically known for.


§1 What Landau's Mechanics is for

Landau-Lifshitz Volume 1 is the originating physics text the Fast Track uses to ground all later mechanics tracks (Arnold 1.11, Cannas 1.11, Souriau 2.11, Woodhouse 3.09). Its distinctive editorial choice: derive all of classical mechanics from the principle of least action. The book opens at §1 with generalised coordinates, reaches Lagrange's equations by §5, and the entire 169-page exposition is one unbroken chain of variational consequences — Lagrangian → conservation laws → integrable problems → small oscillations → rigid body → Hamiltonian → canonical transformations → Hamilton-Jacobi → adiabatic invariants. No Newtonian setup chapter; Newton's first appears at eq. (5.4) as a corollary of the Euler-Lagrange equations for a specific Lagrangian. Galilean relativity (§3) is used to constrain the Lagrangian of a free particle and derive from symmetry alone — a derivation Arnold copies but most physicists do not.

Density: ~30 named results in 169 pp., compared to Arnold's ~120 in 500+ pp. Landau is extremely terse; arguments are often one paragraph, examples are problems with brief solutions, and what Arnold spends a chapter motivating, Landau states in three sentences. Reading Landau is a multiplier on prior mechanics knowledge; reading him as a first source is famously hard.

Distinctive contributions, in roughly the order the book develops them:

  1. Principle of least action as foundational, not derived. §2: the action is the defining object of mechanics; Euler-Lagrange equations $\frac{d}{dt}\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot q_i} - \frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i} = 0$ are derived in two pages.
  2. Galilean-relativity derivation of the free-particle Lagrangian. §4: for a free particle must be a function of alone (isotropy + homogeneity of space + homogeneity of time); Galilean invariance under infinitesimal velocity boost forces ; so up to an additive total derivative. The mass appears as the proportionality constant, not as a primitive.
  3. Mechanical similarity / virial theorem. §10: if then for similar trajectories ; gives Kepler's third law (with ), gives oscillator period independent of amplitude (), gives free-fall law (constant force, ). Landau-distinctive — Arnold does not isolate similarity as a technique.
  4. The reduced-mass / one-body reduction. §13: two-body central problem reduces to one body of reduced mass $\mu = m_1 m_2 / (m_1 + m_2)$ in central field. Standard, but Landau's treatment is the physics-canonical one.
  5. Kepler problem — full solution including the Runge-Lenz vector. §15: orbit equation , time-period via Kepler III, the additional conserved vector named in the §15 problems but not as "Runge-Lenz". Closure of orbits as the signature of the potential.
  6. Scattering: Rutherford's formula and small-angle scattering. §17-§20: cross-section as Jacobian, Rutherford , small-angle scattering, scattering in the laboratory frame (boost from CM to lab — physicist-essential, Arnold-absent).
  7. Small oscillations — full treatment. Ch. V (§§21-30, 36 pp.): 1D harmonic, forced oscillations including resonance, damped, forced+damped, parametric resonance, anharmonic oscillations and nonlinear resonance, normal modes of coupled systems, oscillations of molecules. Landau-canonical; reproduced in virtually every physics curriculum.
  8. Rigid-body dynamics. Ch. VI (§§31-39, 35 pp.): angular velocity, inertia tensor, principal axes, angular momentum of a rigid body, Euler's equations etc., Eulerian angles, the symmetrical top, rigid bodies in contact (rolling, slipping, no-slip constraints), motion in a non-inertial frame (Coriolis, centrifugal). Landau-canonical.
  9. Hamilton's equations / canonical equations. Ch. VII §40: Hamiltonian as Legendre transform, Hamilton's equations , .
  10. Routhian. §41: hybrid Lagrangian-Hamiltonian formulation eliminating cyclic coordinates. Used in physics but rarely in geometric-mechanics texts.
  11. Poisson brackets — full algebraic treatment. §42: definition, Jacobi identity (with explicit operator-commutator proof), Poisson's theorem ( of two integrals is itself an integral), Poisson brackets of angular momentum components.
  12. Action as a function of the coordinates; Maupertuis' principle. §43-§44: , $\partial S / \partial t = -HS_0 = \int p, dq$ minimised at fixed energy. Maupertuis is Landau's bridge to geometric optics and Hamilton-Jacobi.
  13. Canonical transformations and Liouville's theorem. §45-§46: four types of generating functions , invariance of , phase-volume preservation via Jacobian = 1.
  14. Hamilton-Jacobi equation and separation of variables. §47-§48: $\partial S / \partial t + H(q, \partial S / \partial q, t) = 0S(q, t; \alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_s)$, Jacobi's theorem, separation in spherical, parabolic, elliptic coordinates with worked Kepler and two-centre cases.
  15. Adiabatic invariants and canonical action variables. §49-§51: is invariant under slow parameter variation; accuracy of adiabatic conservation (§51) — Landau shows is exponentially small in via contour integration around complex singularities of , a Landau-canonical small-divisor-free derivation. §52 conditionally periodic motion.
  16. Worked Problems as primary pedagogical mechanism. Roughly 251 Problems with solutions, distributed §-by-§. The Problems are not exercises in the modern sense — they are mini-chapters. Examples: Lagrangian of double pendulum (§5 Pr. 1), Kepler in a parabolic orbit, anharmonic oscillator perturbation series, Lagrange's top (§35 Pr. 1), nutation of a symmetrical top.

The book ends before relativistic mechanics (deferred to Vol. 2) and before continuum mechanics (deferred to Vol. 6-7). It also stops short of KAM, perturbation theory beyond Birkhoff, and the modern symplectic-topology programme — those are mid-20th-century and later developments, not Landau's territory.


§2 Coverage table (Codex vs Landau Vol 1)

Cross-referenced against the current Codex corpus (49 units in 05-symplectic/, including the Arnold-MM substitute batch already shipped). ✓ = covered at Landau-equivalent depth, △ = topic present but Landau-distinctive examples / framing not captured, ✗ = not covered.

Chapter I — Equations of Motion (§§1-5, 12 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Generalised coordinates, configuration space (touched in 05.00.01) Coordinate-language framing not isolated; Arnold-MM substitute uses .
Principle of least action (§2) 05.00.02-hamilton-principle Unit exists (Arnold-MM batch); Landau's two-page derivation is the canonical short proof — anchor citation needed.
Galilean relativity, derivation of (§3-§4) 05.00.06-galilean-newtonian-setup Unit shipped; Landau's symmetry-derives-the-Lagrangian argument needs explicit anchor.
Lagrangian for system of particles (§5) 05.00.01-lagrangian-on-tm Coordinate-form not the master statement (which uses ).

Chapter II — Conservation Laws (§§6-10, 12 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Energy conservation from time-translation (§6) (covered in 05.00.04 Noether) Noether-anchored; Landau's coordinate-language derivation is one paragraph and worth quoting in the Beginner tier.
Momentum conservation from space-translation (§7) 05.00.04 Noether Same.
Centre of mass (§8) Gap. Trivially derivable but not isolated as a unit.
Angular momentum (§9) (touched in 05.00.04) Noether-rotational-symmetry. Worked formula not isolated.
Mechanical similarity / virial theorem (§10) Gap (Landau-distinctive). No Codex unit. Kepler III, Bertrand's theorem flavour, isolated as own technique.

Chapter III — Integration of the Equations of Motion (§§11-15, 17 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Motion in 1D, quadrature by energy conservation (§11) Gap. Foundational physics example.
Period of oscillation from potential (§12) Gap. Worked example of inversion technique.
Reduced mass (§13) Gap. Two-body to one-body reduction.
Motion in a central field (§14) Gap. Conservation of , effective potential , orbit equation.
Kepler problem with Runge-Lenz (§15) Gap (Landau-distinctive). Worked-example anchor.

Chapter IV — Collisions Between Particles (§§16-20, 14 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Disintegration / decay (§16) Gap. Physicist-required, math-curriculum-absent.
Elastic collisions (§17) Gap.
Scattering cross-section (§18) Gap. Definition of , lab-frame vs CM-frame.
Rutherford formula (§19) Gap (Landau-distinctive worked example).
Small-angle scattering (§20) Gap.

Chapter V — Small Oscillations (§§21-30, 32 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
1D harmonic oscillator (§21) scattered in Codex examples Not isolated as own unit.
Forced oscillations, resonance (§22) Gap.
Coupled oscillators / normal modes (§23) Gap. Standard physics, Codex-absent.
Molecular vibrations (§24) Gap. Application example.
Damped oscillations (§25) Gap.
Forced + damped (§26) Gap.
Parametric resonance (§27) Gap (Landau-canonical). Mathieu equation territory.
Anharmonic oscillations (§28) Gap. Perturbation series.
Nonlinear resonance (§29) Gap.
Motion in rapidly oscillating field — Kapitza pendulum (§30) Gap (Landau-canonical, originator-prose).

Chapter VI — Motion of a Rigid Body (§§31-39, 33 pp.)

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Angular velocity (§31) Gap.
Inertia tensor (§32) Gap. Physicist-canonical.
Angular momentum of a rigid body (§33) Gap.
Equations of motion of a rigid body (§34) Gap. Newton-Euler equations.
Eulerian angles (§35) Gap. parametrisation, used in QM, robotics.
Euler's equations (§36) (touched in 05.09.05-euler-arnold-equations) Euler-Arnold unit exists at master tier; Landau's coordinate Euler equations on not the beginner-tier focus.
The symmetrical top (§37) Gap (Landau-canonical worked example). Lagrange's top by quadrature.
Rigid bodies in contact / constraints (§38) Gap. Holonomic vs. non-holonomic.
Motion in a non-inertial frame (§39) Gap. Centrifugal + Coriolis force derived from Lagrangian.

Chapter VII — The Canonical Equations (§§40-52, 32 pp.)

Bulk of Codex's existing symplectic chapter lives here. Most items shipped by the Arnold-MM batch.

Landau topic Codex unit Status Note
Hamilton's equations (§40) 05.02.01-hamiltonian-vector-field Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's coordinate-form derivation worth a Beginner-tier anchor.
The Routhian (§41) Gap (Landau-distinctive). Hybrid Lagrangian-Hamiltonian for cyclic coords.
Poisson brackets (§42) 05.02.02-poisson-bracket Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's operator-commutator proof of Jacobi worth anchoring.
Action as function of coordinates (§43) (touched in 05.05.04 Hamilton-Jacobi) , ; folded into HJ unit.
Maupertuis' principle (§44) Gap. Abbreviated action , Jacobi metric; bridge to geodesics.
Canonical transformations (§45) 05.05.03-generating-functions Shipped; Landau's four-types table not fully in master tier.
Liouville's theorem (§46) 05.02.07-liouville-volume Shipped (Arnold-MM).
Hamilton-Jacobi equation (§47) 05.05.04-hamilton-jacobi Shipped (Arnold-MM); separation-of-variables technique (§48) not its own unit.
Separation of variables (§48) Gap. Worked separations (spherical, parabolic, elliptic) including the two-centre Coulomb problem.
Adiabatic invariants (§49) 05.09.02-adiabatic-invariants Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's exponential-accuracy result (§51) is the Landau contribution and is not in the shipped unit.
Canonical variables (action-angle) (§50) 05.02.04-action-angle-coordinates Shipped (Arnold-MM).
Accuracy of conservation of the adiabatic invariant (§51) Gap (Landau-originator). Exponential improvement via complex-contour argument.
Conditionally periodic motion (§52) (touched in 05.02.03 integrable + 05.02.04 action-angle) Shipped (Arnold-MM).

Aggregate coverage estimate

  • Theorem layer: ~40% topic-level, ~30% Landau-equivalent proof-depth. The Hamiltonian half (Ch. VII §§40, 42, 45-47, 49-50) is well-shipped via Arnold-MM substitute batch. The Lagrangian-side worked-example layer (Ch. III-VI: central-field, scattering, small oscillations, rigid body) is almost entirely absent.
  • Exercise / worked-example layer: ~10%. Landau's 251 Problems are the canonical physics problem corpus; Codex has the templated 7-Q pack. Dedicated exercise-pack pass is P3-priority-3 follow-up.
  • Notation layer: ~70%. Major crosswalk concerns:
    • Landau writes for Lagrangian on coordinate space (no tangent-bundle language); Codex uses .
    • Landau writes for angular momentum; Codex / modern geometric texts write or .
    • Landau writes for Hamiltonian, or for Poisson bracket (the latter in §42); Codex uses .
    • Landau's action symbol is for the on-shell action and for the abbreviated action; Codex uses for both contextually.
    • Russian-physics convention puts rather than ; sign conventions on canonical transformations differ from Arnold/Cannas.
  • Sequencing layer: ~50%. Codex orders Lagrangian → Hamiltonian → canonical → HJ; Landau orders identically except he postpones Hamiltonian to Ch. VII (after small oscillations and rigid body). Codex's ordering matches Arnold's, not Landau's.
  • Intuition layer: ~25%. Landau's physicist-intuition (resonance, scattering, similarity, virial) is largely absent from Codex's geometer-flavoured symplectic chapter.
  • Application layer: ~15%. Kepler, Rutherford, Lagrange's top, Coriolis force, normal-mode molecular vibrations — all standard physics examples, absent from Codex.

After priority-1 batch: theorem layer ~60%, application ~50%. After priority-1+2: ~80%, ~75%. Priority-3 brings to ~92%, ~88%. Full ≥95% requires a dedicated Landau-style Problem set.


§3 Gap punch-list (priority-ordered)

The Codex symplectic chapter is mature on the abstract-Hamiltonian side (Arnold-MM-batch already shipped Hamilton-Jacobi, action-angle, adiabatic, KAM, Noether). Landau exposes gaps on (a) the coordinate- physics worked-example layer (Kepler, scattering, small oscillations, rigid body, Coriolis) and (b) a handful of Landau-distinctive items absent from Arnold (mechanical similarity, Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic, Kapitza pendulum, parametric resonance).

Recommended slot ranges:

  • Extend 05.00-lagrangian-mechanics/ with worked examples and Landau-distinctive sections.
  • Extend 05.02-hamiltonian/ with Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic.
  • New 09.* math-physics chapter (or extend 05.00-*) for Newtonian-mechanics worked examples (Kepler, Rutherford, rigid body, small oscillations, Coriolis). Landau's most canonical territory.

Priority 1 — Landau-distinctive load-bearing additions (5 items)

  1. 05.00.08 Mechanical similarity / virial theorem. Landau §10 anchor; Clausius 1870 (virial), Bertrand 1873 (closure of orbits for and potentials only). Three-tier; ~1500 words. Statement: $U(\alpha r) = \alpha^k U(r) \Rightarrow t'/t = (l'/l)^{1-k/2}k = -1$ recovers Kepler III, recovers period-independent oscillator. Master section: virial theorem for homogeneous potentials. Landau-canonical, absent from Arnold-MM batch.

  2. 05.02.10 The Routhian. Landau §41 anchor; Routh 1877 Treatise on the Dynamics of a System of Rigid Bodies originator. Three-tier; ~1400 words. Definition: $R = \sum p_\alpha \dot q_\alpha

    • L$ over cyclic coordinates only, leaving the non-cyclic ones in Lagrangian form. Use case: motion of symmetric top with cyclic precession angle. Landau-distinctive; absent from Arnold-MM batch; appears in physics curricula but not in modern geometric- mechanics texts.
  3. 05.02.11 Maupertuis' principle / abbreviated action. Landau §44 anchor; Maupertuis 1744 Accord de différentes lois de la nature qui avaient jusqu'ici paru incompatibles originator, Euler 1744, Jacobi 1837. Three-tier; ~1600 words. Statement: at fixed energy , over paths with . Master section: Jacobi metric ; reduction of mechanics at fixed energy to geodesic problem in conformally-rescaled metric. Bridge to 05.02.06 geodesic-flow-hamiltonian; complements Arnold-MM batch.

  4. 05.09.07 Exponential accuracy of the adiabatic invariant. Landau §51 anchor; Landau is the originator (the complex-contour argument is his signature contribution to perturbation theory). Three-tier; ~1800 words. Statement: for with analytic in , where is the imaginary part of the nearest complex singularity of from the real axis. Master section: contour-integration proof; comparison with the power-series-only result from averaging. Originator-prose mandatory — paraphrase Landau's §51 directly. Deepens 05.09.02-adiabatic-invariants (which currently has only the leading-order result).

  5. 05.00.09 Worked Lagrangian examples — coordinate-physics layer. Landau Ch. III §§11-15 anchor. Three-tier; ~2200 words. Beginner: 1D motion via energy quadrature (§11), period from potential (§12). Intermediate: reduced-mass two-body (§13), motion in central field with effective potential (§14). Master: full Kepler problem including the Runge-Lenz vector $\mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p} \times \mathbf{M} - m\alpha \hat{\mathbf{r}}$ and orbit closure as -degeneracy signature (§15 Problems). Provides the coordinate-physics worked-example layer Codex currently lacks.

Priority 2 — Landau-canonical physics chapters (5 items)

  1. 05.00.10 Scattering and Rutherford formula. Landau Ch. IV §§16-20 anchor; Rutherford 1911 (Phil. Mag. 21) originator of the formula. Three-tier; ~2000 words. Beginner: cross-section definition as flux/density ratio. Intermediate: elastic-collision kinematics in CM and lab frames; small-angle scattering. Master: Rutherford formula from hyperbolic orbits in central field, with CM-to-lab boost. First collision-theory unit in Codex; downstream prereq for 02.* Section-2 QM scattering.

  2. 05.00.11 Small oscillations and normal modes. Landau Ch. V §§21-23 anchor + §27 parametric resonance. Three-tier; ~2400 words. Beginner: 1D harmonic + forced + damped. Intermediate: coupled oscillators, normal-mode decomposition via eigenvalue problem . Master: parametric resonance from Mathieu equation , instability tongues. Foundational across physics; Codex-absent.

  3. 05.00.12 Kapitza pendulum / motion in rapidly oscillating field. Landau §30 anchor; Kapitza 1951 (Sov. Phys. Usp.) originator. Three-tier; ~1500 words. Master section: effective-potential method, $U_\text{eff} = U + \langle f^2 \rangle / 4 m \omega^2$, inverted-pendulum stabilisation. Landau-Kapitza originator-prose mandatory; canonical physics-pedagogy example absent from Arnold and Codex.

  4. 05.00.13 Rigid-body dynamics — inertia tensor and Eulerian angles. Landau Ch. VI §§31-35 anchor; Euler 1765 Theoria motus corporum solidorum originator. Three-tier; ~2200 words. Beginner: angular velocity vector , inertia tensor . Intermediate: principal axes, angular momentum , equations of motion. Master: Eulerian angles as chart, symmetrical top by quadrature. Complements 05.09.05 Euler-Arnold (which is geometric / coadjoint-orbit framing) with the coordinate-physics counterpart.

  5. 05.00.14 Motion in a non-inertial frame / Coriolis force. Landau §39 anchor; Coriolis 1835 (J. École Polytech.) originator. Three-tier; ~1400 words. Beginner: rotating-frame setup, pseudo-forces. Intermediate: Lagrangian-derivation of centrifugal + Coriolis terms; energy is not conserved in rotating frame, but $E_0 = E - \boldsymbol{\Omega} \cdot \mathbf{M}$ is. Master: Foucault pendulum, weather-system application. Universal physics topic; bridge to 1.03 classical fields and 2.* non-inertial QM.

Priority 3 — depth on existing units, examples, applications (4 items)

  1. Deepen 05.00.02-hamilton-principle. Add a Master-tier section anchored to Landau §2: the two-page canonical derivation of Euler-Lagrange from , with explicit endpoint- fixity and integration-by-parts. Currently the unit cites Arnold; add Landau as joint originator-anchor. No new ID.

  2. Deepen 05.00.06-galilean-newtonian-setup. Add Master-tier section anchored to Landau §3-§4: derive from Galilean invariance + homogeneity + isotropy. Landau- distinctive symmetry-derives-the-Lagrangian argument absent from Arnold. No new ID.

  3. Deepen 05.02.02-poisson-bracket. Add Master-tier proof of Jacobi identity via Landau's §42 operator-commutator argument ( is a first-order operator) — the cleanest elementary proof. No new ID.

  4. Deepen 05.05.03-generating-functions. Tabulate the four types , , , in the master tier per Landau §45 (eqs. (45.7)-(45.8)) — physicist- canonical reference table. Already on Arnold plan priority-3 item 15; no double-count.

Priority 4 — survey / advanced (1 item)

  1. 05.00.15 Separation of variables in Hamilton-Jacobi — elliptic and parabolic. Landau §48 anchor; Jacobi 1837 / Stäckel 1891 originator. Master-only; ~1600 words. Worked separations: central field in spherical, two-centre Coulomb in elliptic, parabolic-cylinder Kepler. Bridge to integrable-systems classics; deferable unless curriculum expands into integrable systems beyond Liouville-Arnold.

§4 Implementation sketch

Minimum Landau-equivalence batch = priority 1 only (items 1-5): 4 new units + 1 deepening. Estimates:

  • ~3 hours per typical new unit; item 5 (worked Lagrangian examples) is ~4.5 h given the worked-example density. Item 4 (exponential- accuracy adiabatic) is ~4 h for originator research.
  • Priority 1: 4 typical × 3 h + 1 worked-example × 4.5 h + 1 originator-prose × 4 h = ~20 hours. Effectively the same envelope as Arnold priority-1.
  • Priority 1+2: ~20 + 5 new × 3.5 h = ~38 hours.
  • Priority 1+2+3 (excl. duplicate items 14): ~38 + 3 deepenings × 1.5 h = ~43 hours.

Originator-prose targets. Landau is partly originator — exponential adiabatic accuracy (item 4) is the Landau contribution. Otherwise he is a synthesizer in the Lagrange-Hamilton-Jacobi-Poisson- Noether tradition. Joint originator-citations:

  • Item 1 (similarity / virial): Clausius 1870 (virial); Bertrand 1873 (closure of orbits).
  • Item 2 (Routhian): Routh 1877.
  • Item 3 (Maupertuis): Maupertuis 1744 / Euler 1744 / Jacobi 1837.
  • Item 4 (exponential adiabatic): Landau §51 — originator, mandatory originator-prose.
  • Item 5 (Kepler / Runge-Lenz): Newton 1687 (Kepler problem); Runge 1919 / Lenz 1924 (the vector).
  • Item 6 (Rutherford): Rutherford 1911.
  • Item 7 (parametric resonance): Mathieu 1868; Faraday 1831 (parametric instability of pendula).
  • Item 8 (Kapitza pendulum): Kapitza 1951 — originator, mandatory originator-prose.
  • Item 9 (rigid body): Euler 1765.
  • Item 10 (Coriolis): Coriolis 1835.

Notation crosswalk concerns (Landau-specific). Recorded inline in the Master sections of each new unit:

  • Lagrangian: Landau writes as a function on coordinate patches; Codex Master-tier writes . Pin the equivalence $L_\text{Landau}(q, \dot q, t) = L_\text{Codex}|_{\text{chart}}(q, v, t)$.
  • Angular momentum symbol: Landau , Codex / . Resolution: keep in Landau-anchored Master sections, write in coordinate-free statements.
  • Sign convention on Hamiltonian: Landau uses (eq. 40.2); Arnold and Cannas agree. No conflict.
  • Sign convention on symplectic form: Landau does not introduce explicitly. Codex's choice $\omega = dp \wedge dq = -d(p, dq)$ matches Arnold; Landau's (implicit in §45) is the same.
  • Russian physicist conventions: Landau writes (kinetic-energy metric); modern math-physics writes $\frac{1}{2}g_{ij}\dot q^i \dot q^ja_{ik} = g_{ik}$ for the configuration metric.
  • Cross-volume notation alert: Landau Vol 1's for action reappears in Vol 2 as the relativistic action . When citing across volumes, disambiguate. (Plan applies to 1.03 audit also.)

DAG edges. New prerequisites for priority-1+2:

  • 05.00.08 (similarity) ← 05.00.02 (Hamilton's principle)
  • 05.02.10 (Routhian) ← {05.02.01, 05.00.01}
  • 05.02.11 (Maupertuis) ← {05.02.05 cotangent-bundle, 05.05.04 Hamilton-Jacobi}; → 05.02.06 geodesic-flow
  • 05.09.07 (exponential adiabatic) ← {05.09.02 adiabatic, 06.01.13 argument-principle / contour integration}
  • 05.00.09 (Lagrangian worked examples) ← 05.00.01-05 Lagrangian block
  • 05.00.10 (scattering) ← 05.00.09 (central field)
  • 05.00.11 (small oscillations) ← 05.00.02
  • 05.00.12 (Kapitza) ← 05.00.11 (parametric resonance)
  • 05.00.13 (rigid body) ← {05.00.01, 03.03.02 group-action, 05.09.05 Euler-Arnold}
  • 05.00.14 (Coriolis) ← 05.00.13

Chapter structure. No new chapter folder needed. Extensions:

  • Extend 05.00-lagrangian-mechanics/: items 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 (plus deepenings 11, 12).
  • Extend 05.02-hamiltonian/: items 2, 3 (plus deepening 13, 14).
  • Extend 05.09-perturbation/ (alias integrable/): item 4.
  • Optional priority-4 item 15 either extends 05.05-lagrangian/ or opens a Master-tier sub-chapter on separation-of-variables.

Composite Arnold + Landau batch. Most efficient production order: because the Arnold-MM substitute batch (priority-1+2 of arnold-mathematical-methods.md) has already shipped 13 of the 17 core units that Landau and Arnold share, this Landau batch is purely Landau-distinctive additions. No re-production of Hamilton's equations, Poisson brackets, action-angle, KAM, Liouville, Hamilton- Jacobi. The Landau plan adds:

  • 4 new Landau-distinctive Hamiltonian-side units (items 1, 2, 3, 4),
  • 6 new physics-canonical Lagrangian/Newtonian-side worked-example units (items 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10) — these are the bulk of the shipped Landau pedagogy and have no Arnold-MM substitute because Arnold dispatches them as Problems in 2 pages.

Apex unit designation. Item 4 (05.09.07 exponential-accuracy adiabatic) is a near-apex unit — originator-prose, requires complex- analysis contour-integration argument that bridges to 06-riemann-surfaces/, paraphrases Landau §51 directly. Not as research-heavy as Arnold-KAM but warrants extended budget.


§5 What this plan does NOT cover

  • Relativistic mechanics. Deferred to Landau Vol 2 Classical Theory of Fields (FT 1.03); separate plan.
  • Continuum / fluid mechanics. Deferred to Vol 6 Fluid Mechanics (not on FT) and Arnold-Khesin (FT 1.12).
  • Statistical mechanics. Deferred to Vol 5 / Souriau (FT 2.10, 2.11).
  • Quantum mechanics. Deferred to Vol 3 (FT 2.01).
  • Line-number Problem inventory. Landau's ~251 Problems form a separate per-section problem corpus. Inventory deferred unless the punch-list expands into a dedicated Landau-exercise-pack pass (analogous to the proposed Arnold-exercise-pack — would be its own ~20-hour pass).
  • The remaining ~30% of Landau worked Problems outside priority-1 items: nutation of symmetrical top, Lagrange points in restricted three-body, oscillations of polyatomic molecules, anharmonic perturbation series, motion of charged particle in EM field as Lagrangian, motion of relativistic particle (deferred to Vol 2).
  • Goldstein / Marion-Thornton parallel-track coverage. Goldstein is cited as a peer source but not separately audited; if a future decision adds Goldstein to FT, dedicated plan. José-Saletan Classical Dynamics same.
  • Russian-language original. Translation differences (Sykes-Bell vs. Russian) not catalogued; physicist-conventions track the English edition.

§6 Acceptance criteria for FT equivalence (Landau Vol 1)

Per docs/plans/FASTTRACK_EQUIVALENCE_PLAN.md §3.4 and §9, Mechanics is at equivalence-coverage when:

  • ≥95% of Landau's named results (and worked formulae) in Chapters I-VII map to Codex units at Landau-equivalent pedagogical depth (currently ~40%; after priority-1 ~60%; after priority-1+2 ~80%; after priority-1+2+3 ~92%; after priority-4 ~95%). Items 4 (exponential adiabatic), 8 (Kapitza), and 9 (rigid body) are the highest-leverage individual gaps.
  • ≥80% of Landau's Problems have a Codex equivalent worked example (currently ~10%; closing requires the Landau-exercise-pack pass per §5).
  • ≥90% of Landau's worked examples appear in a unit (currently ~15%; priority-1+2 brings to ~70%; remainder needs dedicated worked- example densification).
  • Notation crosswalk pinned in Master sections per §4. No standalone notation/landau.md needed.
  • DAG: for every Lagrangian → conservation-law → integrable chain in Landau Chs. I-III (least action → Noether → reduced mass → central field → Kepler), an unbroken prerequisite chain in Codex's DAG. Currently breaks at 05.00.09 (worked Lagrangian examples) — item 5 closes it.
  • Pass-W weaving connects new units to existing 05.00-*, 05.02-*, 05.05-*, 05.09-* and laterally to 06.01.13 (contour integration, for item 4) and 03.03.* (group actions, for items 9-10).

The 4 priority-1 new units (items 1-4) + 1 worked-example unit (item 5) close the Landau-distinctive gap given the Arnold-MM batch is shipped. Priority-2 closes the physics-canonical worked-example layer (items 6-10). Priority-3+4 are deepenings.

Prerequisite alert. Landau Vol 1 sits at FT 1.02 — after the Apostol Vols I (single-variable calculus) and II (multivariable + linear algebra) and Lang Basic Mathematics (FT 0.1, 0.2, 0.3). Codex must keep those prerequisite chains intact: Apostol Vol II calculus-of- variations (Ch. 7) and linear algebra (Ch. 3-5) are load-bearing for items 5, 7, 9, 11. Audit plans tom-m-apostol-calculus-vol-single.md and tom-m-apostol-calculus-vol-multi.md should be checked for any incomplete-coverage gaps that would block Landau units; this Landau plan does not re-audit Apostol.

Honest scope. Mid-sized equivalence gap. The Codex symplectic chapter is mature on the Arnold-geometric side (49 units shipped, of which ~13 already cite Landau-Arnold-equivalent material), but the Landau-canonical physics-pedagogy layer (worked examples, scattering, oscillations, rigid body, Coriolis, similarity, virial, Kapitza, Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic) is almost entirely uncaptured. Priority-1+2 batch is 10 new units + 4 deepenings — comparable to Arnold priority-1+2 in scope but with a different center of mass (Arnold added KAM and Lagrangian-on- infrastructure; Landau adds the physicist worked-example corpus).


§7 Sourcing

  • Status: BUY per docs/catalogs/FASTTRACK_BOOKLIST.md.
  • Local copy resolved: reference/textbooks-extra/Vol 1 - Landau, Lifshitz - Mechanics (3rd ed, 1976).pdf (7.3 MB; also .djvu). Full text accessed for this audit.
  • Citation form: L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, 3rd ed., translated from the Russian by J. B. Sykes and J. S. Bell, Course of Theoretical Physics Volume 1 (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1976; reprinted 2000). ISBN 0 7506 2896 0.
  • Russian original: Mekhanika (Mekhanika), Nauka, Moscow, 1958 (and 1965 / 1973 revisions). Pre-1989 Soviet text — copyright questions are non-trivial; English Pergamon / Butterworth edition remains commercial.
  • Peer sources cited in this audit (peer-anchor for §1):
    • H. Goldstein, C. Poole, J. Safko, Classical Mechanics, 3rd ed. (Addison-Wesley, 2002) — physicist-coordinate companion; canonical American counterpart to Landau.
    • J. Marion, S. Thornton, Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems, 5th ed. (Brooks/Cole, 2003) — undergraduate parallel.
    • V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, Springer GTM 60, 2nd ed. (1989) — geometric counterpart, audit plan at plans/fasttrack/arnold-mathematical-methods.md.
    • J. V. José, E. J. Saletan, Classical Dynamics: A Contemporary Approach (Cambridge UP, 1998) — hybrid coordinate-geometric text; bridge between Landau and Arnold.
  • Additional originator references (cited in §3 punch-list): Lagrange 1788 Mécanique analytique; Hamilton 1834-35 (Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 124, 125); Jacobi 1843 Vorlesungen über Dynamik; Poisson 1809 (J. École Polytech. 8); Noether 1918 (Nachr. König. Ges. Wiss. Göttingen); Rutherford 1911 (Phil. Mag. 21); Kapitza 1951 (Sov. Phys. Usp.); Coriolis 1835 (J. École Polytech.); Euler 1765 Theoria motus corporum solidorum; Maupertuis 1744; Clausius 1870; Bertrand 1873; Routh 1877; Mathieu 1868.
  • Local copy retention. Keep at reference/textbooks-extra/ (the existing path); not promoted into reference/fasttrack-texts/01-fundamentals/ because the fasttrack-texts directory is for free-license / public-domain texts only. Landau remains commercial-copyright; the personal copy stays in the textbooks-extra/ parking area.