Landau, Lifshitz — *Mechanics* (Fast Track 1.02) — Audit + Gap Plan
Book: L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics (Volume 1 of the Course of Theoretical Physics).
- Russian original: Mekhanika, Nauka, Moscow, 1958.
- 3rd English edition: translated by J. B. Sykes and J. S. Bell, Butterworth-Heinemann, 1976; reprinted continuously through 2000. Pagination and section references in this plan are to the 3rd English edition (vii + 169 pp.).
Fast Track entry: 1.02 — the classical-mechanics anchor of Section 1 of the booklist (after 1.01 Shilov Linear Algebra, before 1.03 Classical Theory of Fields). Catalog status: BUY (under active copyright; Pergamon / Butterworth-Heinemann commercial title).
Audit completeness: full. Local PDF resolved at
reference/textbooks-extra/Vol 1 - Landau, Lifshitz - Mechanics (3rd ed, 1976).pdf (7.3 MB, the canonical Sykes-Bell translation). The catalog
flags 1.02 as BUY-only, but a copy was already in
reference/textbooks-extra/; full TOC and key sections (Ch. I-VII)
inventoried directly. WebFetch fallback was not needed.
Purpose: lightweight audit-and-gap pass (P1-lite + P2 + P3-lite).
Output is a punch-list of new units and existing-unit deepenings so that
Mechanics is covered to the FT-equivalence threshold (≥95% effective
coverage; see docs/plans/FASTTRACK_EQUIVALENCE_PLAN.md §3.4). Not a
full P1 audit — Landau's 251 Problems are inventoried at chapter level
only.
Substantial overlap with the Arnold plan
(plans/fasttrack/arnold-mathematical-methods.md). Landau Vol 1 and
Arnold cover the same canonical material — least action, Lagrangian,
Hamiltonian, canonical transformations, Hamilton-Jacobi, action-angle,
adiabatic invariants — with opposite editorial choices (Landau:
physicist-coordinates-first, examples-driven, 169 pp; Arnold:
geometer-manifolds-first, theorem-driven, 500+ pp). The Arnold batch
(items 1-7, 11-13) has already shipped the Codex equivalents of Landau
Chapters I-II and VII. This Landau plan does not double-count those
units; it itemises Landau-distinctive deepenings and the
worked-example layer Landau is canonically known for.
§1 What Landau's Mechanics is for
Landau-Lifshitz Volume 1 is the originating physics text the Fast Track uses to ground all later mechanics tracks (Arnold 1.11, Cannas 1.11, Souriau 2.11, Woodhouse 3.09). Its distinctive editorial choice: derive all of classical mechanics from the principle of least action. The book opens at §1 with generalised coordinates, reaches Lagrange's equations by §5, and the entire 169-page exposition is one unbroken chain of variational consequences — Lagrangian → conservation laws → integrable problems → small oscillations → rigid body → Hamiltonian → canonical transformations → Hamilton-Jacobi → adiabatic invariants. No Newtonian setup chapter; Newton's first appears at eq. (5.4) as a corollary of the Euler-Lagrange equations for a specific Lagrangian. Galilean relativity (§3) is used to constrain the Lagrangian of a free particle and derive from symmetry alone — a derivation Arnold copies but most physicists do not.
Density: ~30 named results in 169 pp., compared to Arnold's ~120 in 500+ pp. Landau is extremely terse; arguments are often one paragraph, examples are problems with brief solutions, and what Arnold spends a chapter motivating, Landau states in three sentences. Reading Landau is a multiplier on prior mechanics knowledge; reading him as a first source is famously hard.
Distinctive contributions, in roughly the order the book develops them:
- Principle of least action as foundational, not derived. §2: the action is the defining object of mechanics; Euler-Lagrange equations $\frac{d}{dt}\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot q_i} - \frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i} = 0$ are derived in two pages.
- Galilean-relativity derivation of the free-particle Lagrangian. §4: for a free particle must be a function of alone (isotropy + homogeneity of space + homogeneity of time); Galilean invariance under infinitesimal velocity boost forces ; so up to an additive total derivative. The mass appears as the proportionality constant, not as a primitive.
- Mechanical similarity / virial theorem. §10: if then for similar trajectories ; gives Kepler's third law (with ), gives oscillator period independent of amplitude (), gives free-fall law (constant force, ). Landau-distinctive — Arnold does not isolate similarity as a technique.
- The reduced-mass / one-body reduction. §13: two-body central problem reduces to one body of reduced mass $\mu = m_1 m_2 / (m_1 + m_2)$ in central field. Standard, but Landau's treatment is the physics-canonical one.
- Kepler problem — full solution including the Runge-Lenz vector. §15: orbit equation , time-period via Kepler III, the additional conserved vector named in the §15 problems but not as "Runge-Lenz". Closure of orbits as the signature of the potential.
- Scattering: Rutherford's formula and small-angle scattering. §17-§20: cross-section as Jacobian, Rutherford , small-angle scattering, scattering in the laboratory frame (boost from CM to lab — physicist-essential, Arnold-absent).
- Small oscillations — full treatment. Ch. V (§§21-30, 36 pp.): 1D harmonic, forced oscillations including resonance, damped, forced+damped, parametric resonance, anharmonic oscillations and nonlinear resonance, normal modes of coupled systems, oscillations of molecules. Landau-canonical; reproduced in virtually every physics curriculum.
- Rigid-body dynamics. Ch. VI (§§31-39, 35 pp.): angular velocity, inertia tensor, principal axes, angular momentum of a rigid body, Euler's equations etc., Eulerian angles, the symmetrical top, rigid bodies in contact (rolling, slipping, no-slip constraints), motion in a non-inertial frame (Coriolis, centrifugal). Landau-canonical.
- Hamilton's equations / canonical equations. Ch. VII §40: Hamiltonian as Legendre transform, Hamilton's equations , .
- Routhian. §41: hybrid Lagrangian-Hamiltonian formulation eliminating cyclic coordinates. Used in physics but rarely in geometric-mechanics texts.
- Poisson brackets — full algebraic treatment. §42: definition, Jacobi identity (with explicit operator-commutator proof), Poisson's theorem ( of two integrals is itself an integral), Poisson brackets of angular momentum components.
- Action as a function of the coordinates; Maupertuis' principle. §43-§44: , $\partial S / \partial t = -HS_0 = \int p, dq$ minimised at fixed energy. Maupertuis is Landau's bridge to geometric optics and Hamilton-Jacobi.
- Canonical transformations and Liouville's theorem. §45-§46: four types of generating functions , invariance of , phase-volume preservation via Jacobian = 1.
- Hamilton-Jacobi equation and separation of variables. §47-§48: $\partial S / \partial t + H(q, \partial S / \partial q, t) = 0S(q, t; \alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_s)$, Jacobi's theorem, separation in spherical, parabolic, elliptic coordinates with worked Kepler and two-centre cases.
- Adiabatic invariants and canonical action variables. §49-§51: is invariant under slow parameter variation; accuracy of adiabatic conservation (§51) — Landau shows is exponentially small in via contour integration around complex singularities of , a Landau-canonical small-divisor-free derivation. §52 conditionally periodic motion.
- Worked Problems as primary pedagogical mechanism. Roughly 251 Problems with solutions, distributed §-by-§. The Problems are not exercises in the modern sense — they are mini-chapters. Examples: Lagrangian of double pendulum (§5 Pr. 1), Kepler in a parabolic orbit, anharmonic oscillator perturbation series, Lagrange's top (§35 Pr. 1), nutation of a symmetrical top.
The book ends before relativistic mechanics (deferred to Vol. 2) and before continuum mechanics (deferred to Vol. 6-7). It also stops short of KAM, perturbation theory beyond Birkhoff, and the modern symplectic-topology programme — those are mid-20th-century and later developments, not Landau's territory.
§2 Coverage table (Codex vs Landau Vol 1)
Cross-referenced against the current Codex corpus (49 units in
05-symplectic/, including the Arnold-MM substitute batch already
shipped). ✓ = covered at Landau-equivalent depth, △ = topic present but
Landau-distinctive examples / framing not captured, ✗ = not covered.
Chapter I — Equations of Motion (§§1-5, 12 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generalised coordinates, configuration space | (touched in 05.00.01) |
△ | Coordinate-language framing not isolated; Arnold-MM substitute uses . |
| Principle of least action (§2) | 05.00.02-hamilton-principle |
△ | Unit exists (Arnold-MM batch); Landau's two-page derivation is the canonical short proof — anchor citation needed. |
| Galilean relativity, derivation of (§3-§4) | 05.00.06-galilean-newtonian-setup |
△ | Unit shipped; Landau's symmetry-derives-the-Lagrangian argument needs explicit anchor. |
| Lagrangian for system of particles (§5) | 05.00.01-lagrangian-on-tm |
△ | Coordinate-form not the master statement (which uses ). |
Chapter II — Conservation Laws (§§6-10, 12 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy conservation from time-translation (§6) | (covered in 05.00.04 Noether) |
△ | Noether-anchored; Landau's coordinate-language derivation is one paragraph and worth quoting in the Beginner tier. |
| Momentum conservation from space-translation (§7) | 05.00.04 Noether |
△ | Same. |
| Centre of mass (§8) | — | ✗ | Gap. Trivially derivable but not isolated as a unit. |
| Angular momentum (§9) | (touched in 05.00.04) |
△ | Noether-rotational-symmetry. Worked formula not isolated. |
| Mechanical similarity / virial theorem (§10) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-distinctive). No Codex unit. Kepler III, Bertrand's theorem flavour, isolated as own technique. |
Chapter III — Integration of the Equations of Motion (§§11-15, 17 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motion in 1D, quadrature by energy conservation (§11) | — | ✗ | Gap. Foundational physics example. |
| Period of oscillation from potential (§12) | — | ✗ | Gap. Worked example of inversion technique. |
| Reduced mass (§13) | — | ✗ | Gap. Two-body to one-body reduction. |
| Motion in a central field (§14) | — | ✗ | Gap. Conservation of , effective potential , orbit equation. |
| Kepler problem with Runge-Lenz (§15) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-distinctive). Worked-example anchor. |
Chapter IV — Collisions Between Particles (§§16-20, 14 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disintegration / decay (§16) | — | ✗ | Gap. Physicist-required, math-curriculum-absent. |
| Elastic collisions (§17) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Scattering cross-section (§18) | — | ✗ | Gap. Definition of , lab-frame vs CM-frame. |
| Rutherford formula (§19) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-distinctive worked example). |
| Small-angle scattering (§20) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
Chapter V — Small Oscillations (§§21-30, 32 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1D harmonic oscillator (§21) | scattered in Codex examples | △ | Not isolated as own unit. |
| Forced oscillations, resonance (§22) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Coupled oscillators / normal modes (§23) | — | ✗ | Gap. Standard physics, Codex-absent. |
| Molecular vibrations (§24) | — | ✗ | Gap. Application example. |
| Damped oscillations (§25) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Forced + damped (§26) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Parametric resonance (§27) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-canonical). Mathieu equation territory. |
| Anharmonic oscillations (§28) | — | ✗ | Gap. Perturbation series. |
| Nonlinear resonance (§29) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Motion in rapidly oscillating field — Kapitza pendulum (§30) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-canonical, originator-prose). |
Chapter VI — Motion of a Rigid Body (§§31-39, 33 pp.)
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angular velocity (§31) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Inertia tensor (§32) | — | ✗ | Gap. Physicist-canonical. |
| Angular momentum of a rigid body (§33) | — | ✗ | Gap. |
| Equations of motion of a rigid body (§34) | — | ✗ | Gap. Newton-Euler equations. |
| Eulerian angles (§35) | — | ✗ | Gap. parametrisation, used in QM, robotics. |
| Euler's equations (§36) | (touched in 05.09.05-euler-arnold-equations) |
△ | Euler-Arnold unit exists at master tier; Landau's coordinate Euler equations on not the beginner-tier focus. |
| The symmetrical top (§37) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-canonical worked example). Lagrange's top by quadrature. |
| Rigid bodies in contact / constraints (§38) | — | ✗ | Gap. Holonomic vs. non-holonomic. |
| Motion in a non-inertial frame (§39) | — | ✗ | Gap. Centrifugal + Coriolis force derived from Lagrangian. |
Chapter VII — The Canonical Equations (§§40-52, 32 pp.)
Bulk of Codex's existing symplectic chapter lives here. Most items shipped by the Arnold-MM batch.
| Landau topic | Codex unit | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hamilton's equations (§40) | 05.02.01-hamiltonian-vector-field |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's coordinate-form derivation worth a Beginner-tier anchor. |
| The Routhian (§41) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-distinctive). Hybrid Lagrangian-Hamiltonian for cyclic coords. |
| Poisson brackets (§42) | 05.02.02-poisson-bracket |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's operator-commutator proof of Jacobi worth anchoring. |
| Action as function of coordinates (§43) | (touched in 05.05.04 Hamilton-Jacobi) |
△ | , ; folded into HJ unit. |
| Maupertuis' principle (§44) | — | ✗ | Gap. Abbreviated action , Jacobi metric; bridge to geodesics. |
| Canonical transformations (§45) | 05.05.03-generating-functions |
△ | Shipped; Landau's four-types table not fully in master tier. |
| Liouville's theorem (§46) | 05.02.07-liouville-volume |
✓ | Shipped (Arnold-MM). |
| Hamilton-Jacobi equation (§47) | 05.05.04-hamilton-jacobi |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM); separation-of-variables technique (§48) not its own unit. |
| Separation of variables (§48) | — | ✗ | Gap. Worked separations (spherical, parabolic, elliptic) including the two-centre Coulomb problem. |
| Adiabatic invariants (§49) | 05.09.02-adiabatic-invariants |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM); Landau's exponential-accuracy result (§51) is the Landau contribution and is not in the shipped unit. |
| Canonical variables (action-angle) (§50) | 05.02.04-action-angle-coordinates |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM). |
| Accuracy of conservation of the adiabatic invariant (§51) | — | ✗ | Gap (Landau-originator). Exponential improvement via complex-contour argument. |
| Conditionally periodic motion (§52) | (touched in 05.02.03 integrable + 05.02.04 action-angle) |
△ | Shipped (Arnold-MM). |
Aggregate coverage estimate
- Theorem layer: ~40% topic-level, ~30% Landau-equivalent proof-depth. The Hamiltonian half (Ch. VII §§40, 42, 45-47, 49-50) is well-shipped via Arnold-MM substitute batch. The Lagrangian-side worked-example layer (Ch. III-VI: central-field, scattering, small oscillations, rigid body) is almost entirely absent.
- Exercise / worked-example layer: ~10%. Landau's 251 Problems are the canonical physics problem corpus; Codex has the templated 7-Q pack. Dedicated exercise-pack pass is P3-priority-3 follow-up.
- Notation layer: ~70%. Major crosswalk concerns:
- Landau writes for Lagrangian on coordinate space (no tangent-bundle language); Codex uses .
- Landau writes for angular momentum; Codex / modern geometric texts write or .
- Landau writes for Hamiltonian, or for Poisson bracket (the latter in §42); Codex uses .
- Landau's action symbol is for the on-shell action and for the abbreviated action; Codex uses for both contextually.
- Russian-physics convention puts rather than ; sign conventions on canonical transformations differ from Arnold/Cannas.
- Sequencing layer: ~50%. Codex orders Lagrangian → Hamiltonian → canonical → HJ; Landau orders identically except he postpones Hamiltonian to Ch. VII (after small oscillations and rigid body). Codex's ordering matches Arnold's, not Landau's.
- Intuition layer: ~25%. Landau's physicist-intuition (resonance, scattering, similarity, virial) is largely absent from Codex's geometer-flavoured symplectic chapter.
- Application layer: ~15%. Kepler, Rutherford, Lagrange's top, Coriolis force, normal-mode molecular vibrations — all standard physics examples, absent from Codex.
After priority-1 batch: theorem layer ~60%, application ~50%. After priority-1+2: ~80%, ~75%. Priority-3 brings to ~92%, ~88%. Full ≥95% requires a dedicated Landau-style Problem set.
§3 Gap punch-list (priority-ordered)
The Codex symplectic chapter is mature on the abstract-Hamiltonian side (Arnold-MM-batch already shipped Hamilton-Jacobi, action-angle, adiabatic, KAM, Noether). Landau exposes gaps on (a) the coordinate- physics worked-example layer (Kepler, scattering, small oscillations, rigid body, Coriolis) and (b) a handful of Landau-distinctive items absent from Arnold (mechanical similarity, Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic, Kapitza pendulum, parametric resonance).
Recommended slot ranges:
- Extend
05.00-lagrangian-mechanics/with worked examples and Landau-distinctive sections. - Extend
05.02-hamiltonian/with Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic. - New
09.*math-physics chapter (or extend05.00-*) for Newtonian-mechanics worked examples (Kepler, Rutherford, rigid body, small oscillations, Coriolis). Landau's most canonical territory.
Priority 1 — Landau-distinctive load-bearing additions (5 items)
05.00.08Mechanical similarity / virial theorem. Landau §10 anchor; Clausius 1870 (virial), Bertrand 1873 (closure of orbits for and potentials only). Three-tier; ~1500 words. Statement: $U(\alpha r) = \alpha^k U(r) \Rightarrow t'/t = (l'/l)^{1-k/2}k = -1$ recovers Kepler III, recovers period-independent oscillator. Master section: virial theorem for homogeneous potentials. Landau-canonical, absent from Arnold-MM batch.05.02.10The Routhian. Landau §41 anchor; Routh 1877 Treatise on the Dynamics of a System of Rigid Bodies originator. Three-tier; ~1400 words. Definition: $R = \sum p_\alpha \dot q_\alpha- L$ over cyclic coordinates only, leaving the non-cyclic ones in Lagrangian form. Use case: motion of symmetric top with cyclic precession angle. Landau-distinctive; absent from Arnold-MM batch; appears in physics curricula but not in modern geometric- mechanics texts.
05.02.11Maupertuis' principle / abbreviated action. Landau §44 anchor; Maupertuis 1744 Accord de différentes lois de la nature qui avaient jusqu'ici paru incompatibles originator, Euler 1744, Jacobi 1837. Three-tier; ~1600 words. Statement: at fixed energy , over paths with . Master section: Jacobi metric ; reduction of mechanics at fixed energy to geodesic problem in conformally-rescaled metric. Bridge to05.02.06geodesic-flow-hamiltonian; complements Arnold-MM batch.05.09.07Exponential accuracy of the adiabatic invariant. Landau §51 anchor; Landau is the originator (the complex-contour argument is his signature contribution to perturbation theory). Three-tier; ~1800 words. Statement: for with analytic in , where is the imaginary part of the nearest complex singularity of from the real axis. Master section: contour-integration proof; comparison with the power-series-only result from averaging. Originator-prose mandatory — paraphrase Landau's §51 directly. Deepens05.09.02-adiabatic-invariants(which currently has only the leading-order result).05.00.09Worked Lagrangian examples — coordinate-physics layer. Landau Ch. III §§11-15 anchor. Three-tier; ~2200 words. Beginner: 1D motion via energy quadrature (§11), period from potential (§12). Intermediate: reduced-mass two-body (§13), motion in central field with effective potential (§14). Master: full Kepler problem including the Runge-Lenz vector $\mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p} \times \mathbf{M} - m\alpha \hat{\mathbf{r}}$ and orbit closure as -degeneracy signature (§15 Problems). Provides the coordinate-physics worked-example layer Codex currently lacks.
Priority 2 — Landau-canonical physics chapters (5 items)
05.00.10Scattering and Rutherford formula. Landau Ch. IV §§16-20 anchor; Rutherford 1911 (Phil. Mag. 21) originator of the formula. Three-tier; ~2000 words. Beginner: cross-section definition as flux/density ratio. Intermediate: elastic-collision kinematics in CM and lab frames; small-angle scattering. Master: Rutherford formula from hyperbolic orbits in central field, with CM-to-lab boost. First collision-theory unit in Codex; downstream prereq for02.*Section-2 QM scattering.05.00.11Small oscillations and normal modes. Landau Ch. V §§21-23 anchor + §27 parametric resonance. Three-tier; ~2400 words. Beginner: 1D harmonic + forced + damped. Intermediate: coupled oscillators, normal-mode decomposition via eigenvalue problem . Master: parametric resonance from Mathieu equation , instability tongues. Foundational across physics; Codex-absent.05.00.12Kapitza pendulum / motion in rapidly oscillating field. Landau §30 anchor; Kapitza 1951 (Sov. Phys. Usp.) originator. Three-tier; ~1500 words. Master section: effective-potential method, $U_\text{eff} = U + \langle f^2 \rangle / 4 m \omega^2$, inverted-pendulum stabilisation. Landau-Kapitza originator-prose mandatory; canonical physics-pedagogy example absent from Arnold and Codex.05.00.13Rigid-body dynamics — inertia tensor and Eulerian angles. Landau Ch. VI §§31-35 anchor; Euler 1765 Theoria motus corporum solidorum originator. Three-tier; ~2200 words. Beginner: angular velocity vector , inertia tensor . Intermediate: principal axes, angular momentum , equations of motion. Master: Eulerian angles as chart, symmetrical top by quadrature. Complements05.09.05Euler-Arnold (which is geometric / coadjoint-orbit framing) with the coordinate-physics counterpart.05.00.14Motion in a non-inertial frame / Coriolis force. Landau §39 anchor; Coriolis 1835 (J. École Polytech.) originator. Three-tier; ~1400 words. Beginner: rotating-frame setup, pseudo-forces. Intermediate: Lagrangian-derivation of centrifugal + Coriolis terms; energy is not conserved in rotating frame, but $E_0 = E - \boldsymbol{\Omega} \cdot \mathbf{M}$ is. Master: Foucault pendulum, weather-system application. Universal physics topic; bridge to1.03classical fields and2.*non-inertial QM.
Priority 3 — depth on existing units, examples, applications (4 items)
Deepen
05.00.02-hamilton-principle. Add a Master-tier section anchored to Landau §2: the two-page canonical derivation of Euler-Lagrange from , with explicit endpoint- fixity and integration-by-parts. Currently the unit cites Arnold; add Landau as joint originator-anchor. No new ID.Deepen
05.00.06-galilean-newtonian-setup. Add Master-tier section anchored to Landau §3-§4: derive from Galilean invariance + homogeneity + isotropy. Landau- distinctive symmetry-derives-the-Lagrangian argument absent from Arnold. No new ID.Deepen
05.02.02-poisson-bracket. Add Master-tier proof of Jacobi identity via Landau's §42 operator-commutator argument ( is a first-order operator) — the cleanest elementary proof. No new ID.Deepen
05.05.03-generating-functions. Tabulate the four types , , , in the master tier per Landau §45 (eqs. (45.7)-(45.8)) — physicist- canonical reference table. Already on Arnold plan priority-3 item 15; no double-count.
Priority 4 — survey / advanced (1 item)
05.00.15Separation of variables in Hamilton-Jacobi — elliptic and parabolic. Landau §48 anchor; Jacobi 1837 / Stäckel 1891 originator. Master-only; ~1600 words. Worked separations: central field in spherical, two-centre Coulomb in elliptic, parabolic-cylinder Kepler. Bridge to integrable-systems classics; deferable unless curriculum expands into integrable systems beyond Liouville-Arnold.
§4 Implementation sketch
Minimum Landau-equivalence batch = priority 1 only (items 1-5): 4 new units + 1 deepening. Estimates:
- ~3 hours per typical new unit; item 5 (worked Lagrangian examples) is ~4.5 h given the worked-example density. Item 4 (exponential- accuracy adiabatic) is ~4 h for originator research.
- Priority 1: 4 typical × 3 h + 1 worked-example × 4.5 h + 1 originator-prose × 4 h = ~20 hours. Effectively the same envelope as Arnold priority-1.
- Priority 1+2: ~20 + 5 new × 3.5 h = ~38 hours.
- Priority 1+2+3 (excl. duplicate items 14): ~38 + 3 deepenings × 1.5 h = ~43 hours.
Originator-prose targets. Landau is partly originator — exponential adiabatic accuracy (item 4) is the Landau contribution. Otherwise he is a synthesizer in the Lagrange-Hamilton-Jacobi-Poisson- Noether tradition. Joint originator-citations:
- Item 1 (similarity / virial): Clausius 1870 (virial); Bertrand 1873 (closure of orbits).
- Item 2 (Routhian): Routh 1877.
- Item 3 (Maupertuis): Maupertuis 1744 / Euler 1744 / Jacobi 1837.
- Item 4 (exponential adiabatic): Landau §51 — originator, mandatory originator-prose.
- Item 5 (Kepler / Runge-Lenz): Newton 1687 (Kepler problem); Runge 1919 / Lenz 1924 (the vector).
- Item 6 (Rutherford): Rutherford 1911.
- Item 7 (parametric resonance): Mathieu 1868; Faraday 1831 (parametric instability of pendula).
- Item 8 (Kapitza pendulum): Kapitza 1951 — originator, mandatory originator-prose.
- Item 9 (rigid body): Euler 1765.
- Item 10 (Coriolis): Coriolis 1835.
Notation crosswalk concerns (Landau-specific). Recorded inline in the Master sections of each new unit:
- Lagrangian: Landau writes as a function on coordinate patches; Codex Master-tier writes . Pin the equivalence $L_\text{Landau}(q, \dot q, t) = L_\text{Codex}|_{\text{chart}}(q, v, t)$.
- Angular momentum symbol: Landau , Codex / . Resolution: keep in Landau-anchored Master sections, write in coordinate-free statements.
- Sign convention on Hamiltonian: Landau uses (eq. 40.2); Arnold and Cannas agree. No conflict.
- Sign convention on symplectic form: Landau does not introduce explicitly. Codex's choice $\omega = dp \wedge dq = -d(p, dq)$ matches Arnold; Landau's (implicit in §45) is the same.
- Russian physicist conventions: Landau writes (kinetic-energy metric); modern math-physics writes $\frac{1}{2}g_{ij}\dot q^i \dot q^ja_{ik} = g_{ik}$ for the configuration metric.
- Cross-volume notation alert: Landau Vol 1's for action
reappears in Vol 2 as the relativistic action .
When citing across volumes, disambiguate. (Plan applies to
1.03audit also.)
DAG edges. New prerequisites for priority-1+2:
05.00.08(similarity) ←05.00.02(Hamilton's principle)05.02.10(Routhian) ← {05.02.01,05.00.01}05.02.11(Maupertuis) ← {05.02.05cotangent-bundle,05.05.04Hamilton-Jacobi}; →05.02.06geodesic-flow05.09.07(exponential adiabatic) ← {05.09.02adiabatic,06.01.13argument-principle / contour integration}05.00.09(Lagrangian worked examples) ←05.00.01-05Lagrangian block05.00.10(scattering) ←05.00.09(central field)05.00.11(small oscillations) ←05.00.0205.00.12(Kapitza) ←05.00.11(parametric resonance)05.00.13(rigid body) ← {05.00.01,03.03.02group-action,05.09.05Euler-Arnold}05.00.14(Coriolis) ←05.00.13
Chapter structure. No new chapter folder needed. Extensions:
- Extend
05.00-lagrangian-mechanics/: items 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 (plus deepenings 11, 12). - Extend
05.02-hamiltonian/: items 2, 3 (plus deepening 13, 14). - Extend
05.09-perturbation/(aliasintegrable/): item 4. - Optional priority-4 item 15 either extends
05.05-lagrangian/or opens a Master-tier sub-chapter on separation-of-variables.
Composite Arnold + Landau batch. Most efficient production order:
because the Arnold-MM substitute batch (priority-1+2 of
arnold-mathematical-methods.md) has already shipped 13 of the 17 core
units that Landau and Arnold share, this Landau batch is purely
Landau-distinctive additions. No re-production of Hamilton's
equations, Poisson brackets, action-angle, KAM, Liouville, Hamilton-
Jacobi. The Landau plan adds:
- 4 new Landau-distinctive Hamiltonian-side units (items 1, 2, 3, 4),
- 6 new physics-canonical Lagrangian/Newtonian-side worked-example units (items 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10) — these are the bulk of the shipped Landau pedagogy and have no Arnold-MM substitute because Arnold dispatches them as Problems in 2 pages.
Apex unit designation. Item 4 (05.09.07 exponential-accuracy
adiabatic) is a near-apex unit — originator-prose, requires complex-
analysis contour-integration argument that bridges to
06-riemann-surfaces/, paraphrases Landau §51 directly. Not as
research-heavy as Arnold-KAM but warrants extended budget.
§5 What this plan does NOT cover
- Relativistic mechanics. Deferred to Landau Vol 2 Classical Theory of Fields (FT 1.03); separate plan.
- Continuum / fluid mechanics. Deferred to Vol 6 Fluid Mechanics (not on FT) and Arnold-Khesin (FT 1.12).
- Statistical mechanics. Deferred to Vol 5 / Souriau (FT 2.10, 2.11).
- Quantum mechanics. Deferred to Vol 3 (FT 2.01).
- Line-number Problem inventory. Landau's ~251 Problems form a separate per-section problem corpus. Inventory deferred unless the punch-list expands into a dedicated Landau-exercise-pack pass (analogous to the proposed Arnold-exercise-pack — would be its own ~20-hour pass).
- The remaining ~30% of Landau worked Problems outside priority-1 items: nutation of symmetrical top, Lagrange points in restricted three-body, oscillations of polyatomic molecules, anharmonic perturbation series, motion of charged particle in EM field as Lagrangian, motion of relativistic particle (deferred to Vol 2).
- Goldstein / Marion-Thornton parallel-track coverage. Goldstein is cited as a peer source but not separately audited; if a future decision adds Goldstein to FT, dedicated plan. José-Saletan Classical Dynamics same.
- Russian-language original. Translation differences (Sykes-Bell vs. Russian) not catalogued; physicist-conventions track the English edition.
§6 Acceptance criteria for FT equivalence (Landau Vol 1)
Per docs/plans/FASTTRACK_EQUIVALENCE_PLAN.md §3.4 and §9, Mechanics
is at equivalence-coverage when:
- ≥95% of Landau's named results (and worked formulae) in Chapters I-VII map to Codex units at Landau-equivalent pedagogical depth (currently ~40%; after priority-1 ~60%; after priority-1+2 ~80%; after priority-1+2+3 ~92%; after priority-4 ~95%). Items 4 (exponential adiabatic), 8 (Kapitza), and 9 (rigid body) are the highest-leverage individual gaps.
- ≥80% of Landau's Problems have a Codex equivalent worked example (currently ~10%; closing requires the Landau-exercise-pack pass per §5).
- ≥90% of Landau's worked examples appear in a unit (currently ~15%; priority-1+2 brings to ~70%; remainder needs dedicated worked- example densification).
- Notation crosswalk pinned in Master sections per §4. No standalone
notation/landau.mdneeded. - DAG: for every Lagrangian → conservation-law → integrable chain in
Landau Chs. I-III (least action → Noether → reduced mass → central
field → Kepler), an unbroken prerequisite chain in Codex's DAG.
Currently breaks at
05.00.09(worked Lagrangian examples) — item 5 closes it. - Pass-W weaving connects new units to existing
05.00-*,05.02-*,05.05-*,05.09-*and laterally to06.01.13(contour integration, for item 4) and03.03.*(group actions, for items 9-10).
The 4 priority-1 new units (items 1-4) + 1 worked-example unit (item 5) close the Landau-distinctive gap given the Arnold-MM batch is shipped. Priority-2 closes the physics-canonical worked-example layer (items 6-10). Priority-3+4 are deepenings.
Prerequisite alert. Landau Vol 1 sits at FT 1.02 — after the
Apostol Vols I (single-variable calculus) and II (multivariable +
linear algebra) and Lang Basic Mathematics (FT 0.1, 0.2, 0.3). Codex
must keep those prerequisite chains intact: Apostol Vol II calculus-of-
variations (Ch. 7) and linear algebra (Ch. 3-5) are load-bearing for
items 5, 7, 9, 11. Audit plans
tom-m-apostol-calculus-vol-single.md and
tom-m-apostol-calculus-vol-multi.md should be checked for any
incomplete-coverage gaps that would block Landau units; this Landau
plan does not re-audit Apostol.
Honest scope. Mid-sized equivalence gap. The Codex symplectic chapter is mature on the Arnold-geometric side (49 units shipped, of which ~13 already cite Landau-Arnold-equivalent material), but the Landau-canonical physics-pedagogy layer (worked examples, scattering, oscillations, rigid body, Coriolis, similarity, virial, Kapitza, Routhian, Maupertuis, exponential-accuracy adiabatic) is almost entirely uncaptured. Priority-1+2 batch is 10 new units + 4 deepenings — comparable to Arnold priority-1+2 in scope but with a different center of mass (Arnold added KAM and Lagrangian-on- infrastructure; Landau adds the physicist worked-example corpus).
§7 Sourcing
- Status: BUY per
docs/catalogs/FASTTRACK_BOOKLIST.md. - Local copy resolved:
reference/textbooks-extra/Vol 1 - Landau, Lifshitz - Mechanics (3rd ed, 1976).pdf(7.3 MB; also.djvu). Full text accessed for this audit. - Citation form: L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, 3rd ed., translated from the Russian by J. B. Sykes and J. S. Bell, Course of Theoretical Physics Volume 1 (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1976; reprinted 2000). ISBN 0 7506 2896 0.
- Russian original: Mekhanika (Mekhanika), Nauka, Moscow, 1958 (and 1965 / 1973 revisions). Pre-1989 Soviet text — copyright questions are non-trivial; English Pergamon / Butterworth edition remains commercial.
- Peer sources cited in this audit (peer-anchor for §1):
- H. Goldstein, C. Poole, J. Safko, Classical Mechanics, 3rd ed. (Addison-Wesley, 2002) — physicist-coordinate companion; canonical American counterpart to Landau.
- J. Marion, S. Thornton, Classical Dynamics of Particles and Systems, 5th ed. (Brooks/Cole, 2003) — undergraduate parallel.
- V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics,
Springer GTM 60, 2nd ed. (1989) — geometric counterpart, audit
plan at
plans/fasttrack/arnold-mathematical-methods.md. - J. V. José, E. J. Saletan, Classical Dynamics: A Contemporary Approach (Cambridge UP, 1998) — hybrid coordinate-geometric text; bridge between Landau and Arnold.
- Additional originator references (cited in §3 punch-list): Lagrange 1788 Mécanique analytique; Hamilton 1834-35 (Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 124, 125); Jacobi 1843 Vorlesungen über Dynamik; Poisson 1809 (J. École Polytech. 8); Noether 1918 (Nachr. König. Ges. Wiss. Göttingen); Rutherford 1911 (Phil. Mag. 21); Kapitza 1951 (Sov. Phys. Usp.); Coriolis 1835 (J. École Polytech.); Euler 1765 Theoria motus corporum solidorum; Maupertuis 1744; Clausius 1870; Bertrand 1873; Routh 1877; Mathieu 1868.
- Local copy retention. Keep at
reference/textbooks-extra/(the existing path); not promoted intoreference/fasttrack-texts/01-fundamentals/because the fasttrack-texts directory is for free-license / public-domain texts only. Landau remains commercial-copyright; the personal copy stays in thetextbooks-extra/parking area.