Entropy in chemistry: the third law, standard entropy changes, and the Gibbs energy
Anchor (Master): Nernst — Nachr. Ges. Wiss. Gottingen, Math-Phys. Kl. (1906); Planck — Thermodynamik, 3e (1911)
Intuition Beginner
Entropy measures how spread out energy and matter are across possible arrangements. A gas in a small flask has lower entropy than the same gas in a large room because the molecules in the room can occupy many more positions. When a process increases the number of accessible arrangements, entropy increases.
The second law of thermodynamics states that the total entropy of the universe always increases for a spontaneous process. For a chemical reaction, this means . Entropy is a state function: its change depends only on the initial and final states, not on the path taken.
But tracking the entropy of the entire universe is impractical. The Gibbs free energy collapses everything into a single number for the system. It is defined as , where is enthalpy, is temperature, and is entropy. At constant temperature and pressure, . A reaction is spontaneous when , at equilibrium when , and non-spontaneous when .
The sign of is a competition between enthalpy and entropy. An exothermic reaction () with increasing disorder () is spontaneous at all temperatures. An endothermic reaction () with decreasing disorder () is never spontaneous. The two mixed cases depend on temperature.
Visual Beginner
The spontaneity of a reaction depends on the signs of and . The table below summarises all four combinations:
| Spontaneous at all | Spontaneous at low | |
| Spontaneous at high | Never spontaneous |
The crossover temperature where spontaneity changes is , where .
Worked example Beginner
Calculate the standard entropy change for the combustion of methane at 298 K:
Standard molar entropies at 298 K (all in J/(mol K)): , , , .
= (total standard entropy of all products) (total standard entropy of all reactants)
The entropy of the system decreases. Three moles of gas produce one mole of gas and two moles of liquid, so the system becomes more ordered. But the reaction releases a large amount of heat ( kJ/mol), and this heat increases the entropy of the surroundings enormously. The total J/mol. The reaction is strongly spontaneous despite the entropy decrease of the system.
Check your understanding Beginner
Formal definition Intermediate+
Entropy as a state function and the second law
Entropy is a state function. Its change between two states depends only on the endpoints, not on the path. For a reversible process at constant temperature, the entropy change of the system is
where is the heat transferred in a reversible process connecting the initial and final states. Because is a state function, can be computed along any convenient reversible path, even if the actual process is irreversible.
The second law of thermodynamics states that for any spontaneous process,
The entropy change of the surroundings is
for a process occurring at constant external temperature. For a reaction at constant pressure, , so
Multiplying both sides by :
Since for a spontaneous process, , giving . This is the fundamental link: the Gibbs free energy criterion is equivalent to the second law expressed for constant- processes.
The third law and absolute entropy
The third law of thermodynamics (Nernst heat theorem, 1906; Planck formulation, 1911) states that the entropy of a perfect crystalline substance approaches zero as temperature approaches absolute zero:
A perfect crystal has a unique ground-state arrangement. There is only one way to arrange the atoms, so the number of microstates is , and by Boltzmann's entropy formula .
The third law provides an absolute reference point for entropy. Unlike enthalpy (where only changes are measurable), entropy has a natural zero. The absolute entropy of a substance at any temperature is obtained by integrating the heat capacity:
In practice, heat-capacity measurements from near 0 K up to the temperature of interest are used. Phase transitions (melting, boiling) contribute at each transition temperature.
Standard molar entropies
The standard molar entropy is the absolute entropy of one mole of a substance in its standard state (pure substance at 1 bar pressure and a specified temperature, usually 298 K). Key trends:
- increases with molecular complexity. ( J/(mol K)) has higher entropy than Ar ( J/(mol K)) because more atoms mean more vibrational and rotational degrees of freedom.
- increases from solid to liquid to gas. has J/(mol K); has J/(mol K).
- increases with temperature because higher populates more molecular energy levels.
- Dissolved ions have standard entropies referenced to by convention, not from the third law directly.
For a chemical reaction , the standard entropy change is
with for products and for reactants. This is the same bookkeeping pattern used for enthalpy changes via Hess's law.
Standard Gibbs energy of reaction
The standard Gibbs energy of reaction is
Alternatively, using standard Gibbs energies of formation (tabulated for most compounds; for elements in their reference form):
The two methods give identical results. The formation-enthalpy-plus-entropy route is useful when you want to analyse how temperature affects spontaneity; the formation-Gibbs-energy route is useful when you only need at 298 K.
Worked example at intermediate level
Predict the spontaneity of the decomposition of calcium carbonate at 298 K and at 1200 K:
Data at 298 K: , , kJ/mol. , , J/(mol K).
Step 1: Enthalpy change.
Step 2: Entropy change.
The positive makes sense: a solid produces a solid plus a gas, increasing the number of accessible molecular arrangements.
Step 3: Gibbs energy at 298 K.
Non-spontaneous at 298 K.
Step 4: Crossover temperature.
Step 5: At 1200 K.
Spontaneous at 1200 K. Calcium carbonate decomposes above about 1121 K (848C), consistent with industrial lime production in kilns at 900-1100C.
Key result Intermediate+
Calorimetric vs spectroscopic entropy: testing the third law
The third law predicts that calorimetric entropy (from heat-capacity integration) and spectroscopic entropy (from partition functions) should agree for perfect crystals. Experimental data confirm this and reveal exceptions with physical explanations:
| Substance | (J/(mol K)) | (J/(mol K)) | Deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 192.0 | 191.6 | 0.4 | |
| 205.4 | 205.2 | 0.2 | |
| 186.2 | 186.8 | 0.6 | |
| 193.3 | 197.9 | 4.6 |
Nitrogen, oxygen, and hydrogen chloride agree within experimental uncertainty. Carbon monoxide deviates by 4.6 J/(mol K), close to J/(mol K), revealing residual entropy from disordered CO/OC orientations frozen into the crystal lattice.
Trouton's rule across substances
Trouton's rule ( J/(mol K) for most liquids) holds across diverse substances, confirming that the entropy increase on vaporisation is governed by a common mechanism (gain of translational freedom):
| Substance | (K) | (J/(mol K)) |
|---|---|---|
| Benzene | 353 | 87.3 |
| 350 | 85.7 | |
| Diethyl ether | 308 | 84.4 |
| Water | 373 | 109.0 |
Water is a notable outlier because hydrogen bonding lowers the entropy of the liquid, making the entropy gain on vaporisation larger than typical.
CaCO3 decomposition: Gibbs energy predicts industrial practice
The worked example above predicts that calcium carbonate decomposes spontaneously above 1121 K. Industrial lime kilns operate at 900--1100 C (1173--1373 K), consistent with this prediction. The thermodynamic crossover temperature directly determines the minimum operating temperature for one of the world's oldest and largest-scale chemical processes.
Exercises Intermediate
The third law, residual entropy, and the thermodynamic temperature scale Master
Nernst heat theorem and Planck's formulation
The Nernst heat theorem (1906) states that for any isothermal process between equilibrium states of a condensed system (solid or liquid), the entropy change approaches zero as temperature approaches absolute zero:
Nernst arrived at this by extrapolating measurements of the Gibbs energy and enthalpy of chemical reactions at low temperatures. He observed that and converge as (since , this means ), and he postulated the stronger statement that itself, not merely .
Planck (1911) strengthened the theorem to an absolute statement about individual substances: the entropy of every chemically homogeneous solid or liquid approaches zero at . Combined with Boltzmann's , this means that a perfect crystal at has exactly one microstate (). The Planck formulation converts entropy from a quantity defined only up to an additive constant into one with an absolute zero, making standard molar entropies physical quantities that can be measured and tabulated without ambiguity.
The third law has consequences beyond providing an entropy zero. It implies that heat capacities vanish at absolute zero: and as . This follows because must converge to a finite value, which requires the integrand to vanish at least as fast as . The Debye law for the low-temperature heat capacity of insulators () satisfies this requirement. The coefficient of thermal expansion also vanishes as , a result that follows from the Maxwell relation and the third law: since independent of , , forcing .
Residual entropy and disorder in crystals
Not all crystals satisfy at . Carbon monoxide, CO, crystallises with the molecules oriented nearly randomly as either CO or OC in the lattice. The resulting residual entropy is per molecule J/(mol K), close to the measured discrepancy between calorimetric and spectroscopic entropies. Ice Ih has residual entropy from the proton disorder on the hydrogen-bond network: each water molecule donates two and accepts two hydrogen bonds, but there are multiple configurations satisfying this constraint. Pauling (1935) estimated J/(mol K), in good agreement with experiment ( J/(mol K)).
These exceptions do not violate the third law. The law applies to a perfect crystal in its unique ground state. Real crystals that freeze in configurational disorder retain residual entropy because they are kinetically trapped in metastable states, not because the true ground state has . The distinction between thermodynamic equilibrium (the perfect crystal) and the kinetically frozen state is essential: the third law describes the entropy at equilibrium, not the entropy of whatever configuration the laboratory sample happens to adopt.
Absolute entropy from calorimetry and spectroscopy
The absolute entropy of a gas at temperature is obtained by integrating from 0 K through all phase transitions up to , with each phase transition contributing :
For ideal gases, the calorimetric entropy can be compared with the statistical entropy computed from molecular partition functions. The Sackur-Tetrode equation gives the translational entropy of a monatomic ideal gas:
and the rotational and vibrational contributions are added from the corresponding partition-function factors. Agreement between calorimetric and statistical entropies to within experimental uncertainty is a stringent test of the consistency of the third law, heat-capacity data, and spectroscopic constants. Discrepancies reveal residual entropy (CO, ice) or the need for revised spectroscopic assignments.
Gibbs free energy, spontaneity, and the Gibbs-Helmholtz equation Master
The Gibbs energy as a thermodynamic potential
The Gibbs free energy is the fourth thermodynamic potential obtained by Legendre-transforming the internal energy twice:
Its natural variables are , , and the mole numbers . The differential form for an open multicomponent system is
where is the chemical potential of species . At constant and , , and the equilibrium condition is (stationarity) with (stability, i.e., a true minimum).
The Gibbs energy is the maximum non-expansion work obtainable from a process at constant and . For a reversible electrochemical cell, , where is the number of moles of electrons transferred, is the Faraday constant, and is the cell potential. This identification bridges chemical thermodynamics to electrochemistry.
The Gibbs-Helmholtz equation
The Gibbs-Helmholtz equation gives the temperature dependence of :
Proof. Compute as a function of at constant :
Since , we have . Substituting:
Applied to a chemical reaction, the Gibbs-Helmholtz equation becomes
Combined with , this yields the van't Hoff equation:
The Gibbs-Helmholtz equation is the thermodynamic engine behind all predictions of how equilibrium shifts with temperature. It requires only the enthalpy (measurable by calorimetry) and links it to the temperature dependence of the Gibbs energy (measurable by equilibrium measurements or electrochemistry).
Temperature dependence of spontaneity
For a reaction with approximately temperature-independent and , the Gibbs energy is linear in temperature:
The four cases follow directly:
- , : at all . Both terms favour spontaneity.
- , : at all . Neither term favours spontaneity.
- , : at low , at high . Crossover at .
- , : at low , at high . Crossover at .
When and are temperature-dependent (through the difference in heat capacities ), the linear approximation breaks down and becomes a nontrivial function. The Kirchhoff equations give and . Integrating these with a temperature-dependent (often expressed as a polynomial from the Shomate or NIST-JANAF tables) gives accurate predictions of over wide temperature ranges.
The pressure dependence of Gibbs energy
From at constant composition, the pressure dependence of the Gibbs energy at constant temperature is
For an ideal gas, , so integrating from standard pressure bar to arbitrary pressure :
For a pure liquid or solid, is approximately constant, giving . Because molar volumes of condensed phases are small ( cm/mol), the pressure dependence of for solids and liquids is negligible at moderate pressures. This justifies setting the activity of pure solids and liquids to unity in the equilibrium-constant expression.
For gas-phase reactions with a change in the number of moles (), pressure affects through the reaction quotient . At constant , increasing total pressure shifts equilibrium toward the side with fewer gas moles because the contribution per mole of gas adds up more on the side with more gas moles. This is the quantitative basis of Le Chatelier's pressure principle.
Connections Master
Chemical thermodynamics and equilibrium
14.06.01. This unit extends the Gibbs energy framework from the prerequisite unit. Where 14.06.01 develops as a thermodynamic potential and derives , this unit adds the third law, absolute entropy, the calorimetric determination of , and the detailed temperature-dependence analysis through the Gibbs-Helmholtz equation.Statistical mechanics
14.07.01. The Boltzmann formula provides the microscopic foundation for the third law ( for a perfect crystal at ). The Sackur-Tetrode equation and partition-function entropy calculations give independent spectroscopic values for that can be compared with calorimetric measurements.Electrochemistry
14.11.01. The identification connects the Gibbs energy to the measurable cell potential. The Nernst equation is the electrochemical restatement of .Chemical kinetics
14.08.01. The distinction between (thermodynamic spontaneity) and a fast reaction is the thermodynamics-kinetics divide. A catalyst lowers the activation energy without changing , accelerating the approach to equilibrium without shifting its position.Acid-base chemistry
14.10.01. The acid dissociation constant is an instance of the general equilibrium constant applied to proton transfer. The pH scale is a logarithmic measure of the proton chemical potential.Solutions and phase equilibria
14.09.01. The entropy of mixing, Raoult's law, and colligative properties all follow from the Gibbs energy framework. The Gibbs-Duhem equation constrains how chemical potentials co-vary in a mixture.Metabolic thermodynamics
17.04.01. Living cells operate at constant and , making the natural thermodynamic potential. ATP hydrolysis ( kJ/mol at pH 7) drives coupled reactions through the additivity of .
Historical context Master
The concept of entropy was introduced by Rudolf Clausius in 1865 as the thermodynamic quantity that always increases in spontaneous processes. Clausius chose the name from the Greek ("the transformation"), reflecting entropy's role as the measure of energy's dispersal. His statement "the entropy of the universe tends to a maximum" was the first clear articulation of the second law in terms of entropy rather than heat engines.
The third law emerged from Walther Nernst's 1906 investigations of chemical equilibria at low temperatures. Nernst observed that the Gibbs energies and enthalpies of reactions converged as temperature decreased, and he postulated that as for condensed-phase reactions. Max Planck strengthened this in 1911 to the absolute statement that for a perfect crystal, giving entropy a natural zero point. The Nernst-Planck formulation resolved a fundamental problem: without the third law, thermodynamics defines only entropy changes, and the absolute entropy of any substance is undetermined. With the third law, becomes a measurable, tabulated quantity.
The Gibbs energy was introduced by J. Willard Gibbs in his 1876-78 monograph On the Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances, where he defined the chemical potential and derived the conditions for chemical and phase equilibrium. Gibbs's (he called it the "thermodynamic potential at constant temperature and pressure") unified the enthalpy-entropy tension into a single criterion for spontaneity. The Gibbs-Helmholtz equation was developed independently by Gibbs and Helmholtz in the early 1880s; Helmholtz's formulation emphasised the connection between the free energy and the maximum work obtainable from a chemical process.
Trouton's rule (1884), which states that J/(mol K) for most liquids at their normal boiling points, was an early empirical observation that finds its explanation in the statistical mechanics of translational entropy. Water's anomalously high J/(mol K) reflects the low entropy of liquid water due to its hydrogen-bond network.
Bibliography Master
@article{Nernst1906,
author = {Nernst, W.},
title = {Ueber die Berechnung chemischer Gleichgewichte aus thermischen Messungen},
journal = {Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Gottingen, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse},
year = {1906},
pages = {1--40}
}
@book{Planck1911,
author = {Planck, M.},
title = {Vorlesungen uber Thermodynamik},
edition = {3},
publisher = {Veit, Leipzig},
year = {1911}
}
@article{Clausius1865,
author = {Clausius, R.},
title = {Ueber verschiedene fur die Anwendung bequeme Formen der Hauptgleichungen der mechanischen Warmetheorie},
journal = {Annalen der Physik und Chemie},
volume = {125},
year = {1865},
pages = {353--400}
}
@article{Pauling1935,
author = {Pauling, L.},
title = {The Structure and Entropy of Ice and of Other Crystals with Some Randomness of Atomic Arrangement},
journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
volume = {57},
year = {1935},
pages = {2680--2684}
}
@article{Gibbs1878,
author = {Gibbs, J. W.},
title = {On the Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances},
journal = {Transactions of the Connecticut Academy of Arts and Sciences},
volume = {3},
year = {1876--1878},
pages = {108--248, 343--524}
}
@book{ZumdahlDeCoste2017,
author = {Zumdahl, S. S. and DeCoste, D. J.},
title = {Chemical Principles},
edition = {8},
publisher = {Cengage},
year = {2017}
}
@book{AtkinsPaula2023,
author = {Atkins, P. and de Paula, J.},
title = {Physical Chemistry},
edition = {12},
publisher = {Oxford University Press},
year = {2023}
}
@book{EngelReid2019,
author = {Engel, T. and Reid, P.},
title = {Thermodynamics, Statistical Thermodynamics, and Kinetics},
edition = {4},
publisher = {Pearson},
year = {2019}
}
@book{Callen1985,
author = {Callen, H. B.},
title = {Thermodynamics and an Introduction to Thermostatistics},
edition = {2},
publisher = {Wiley},
year = {1985}
}